Digital Sustainability

Data is central to everything we do, presenting many opportunities for progress in our digital world. And yet, the question of how to store data raises many sustainability concerns. In this chapter we explore three possible approaches under which the sustainable operation of data centers will be possible in the future.

  • Download

Introduction

Data is everything and powers everything we do, from cloud solutions to 5G real-time communications. However, as our usage of data grows, the question of how to store this increasing amount of data presents its own challenges. 

Data centers are at the core of this solution, and we see an increasing number of newly built data centers (greenfield projects) around the globe, in particular, concentrated in certain hubs (like Frankfurt, Amsterdam or Paris) on Continental Europe. While being an attractive asset class, this trend is also accompanied by sustainability challenges given the huge amount of power and energy consumption for cooling purposes.

This can be vividly demonstrated by the example of Ireland. In 2022, according to the Central Statistics Office (CSO), data centers used almost a fifth of the Irish electricity. Furthermore, as a trend it can be recognized that the amount of electricity required by data centers has increased rapidly in Ireland over the past few years. Since 2015, it has increased by 400%. Thus, the question of whether data centers can be operated in a sustainable manner is quite pressing, considering their increased energy demand. Some countries have responded to the increased demand for energy by imposing a moratorium on data center projects. Singapore, for example, imposed a moratorium on new data center projects in 2019 which was then only lifted in 2022 when stricter sustainability requirements were demanded instead. 

Since there is also a political agenda to attract data centers and thereby “control” the storage of data, it is rather unlikely that a country will be able to impose moratoriums in the future. Instead of simply prohibiting data center projects, a solution has to be found for operating data centers in a sustainable manner. 

Ireland’s Climate Minister Eamon Ryan addressed the environmental issues evoked by data centers at the National Economic Dialogue by stating that every single data center should come up with flexible systems to deliver low carbon electricity and think of ways to use the waste heat effectively. When it comes to the operation of data centers, the trend in the future must be to move away from the mere consumption of energy to the production of self-obtained energy. Furthermore, the produced thermal energy needs to be used effectively. This chapter will present three – possible – approaches under which the sustainable operation of data centers will be possible in the future, with reference to projects already intended in some countries in this area.

Quote

When it comes to the operation of data centers, the trend in the future must be to move away from the mere consumption of energy to the production of self-obtained energy.

Quote

If data centers were able to generate at least some of the energy they needed themselves, they would be classified as more sustainable from an ESG perspective.

How can data centers become a renewable utility?

Option 1 – Producing energy on-site via solar

Purchasing ‘green electricity’ from the grid is considered  “state-of-the-art” for most data centers. However, data centers maybe be used to produce energy themselves. If data centers were able to generate at least some of the energy they needed themselves, they would be classified as more sustainable from an ESG perspective. One obvious way to generate energy would be to use rooftop solar panels. Since data centers often have a large surface area, if not hindered by cooling systems or other stability elements, and an increasing number of data centers use solar panels on their rooftop. This, of course, only provides a small contribution to the overall consumption. 

Option 2 – Being powered by hydrogen on-site generators 

Powering data centers on-site, can be further enhanced by replacing typically gas (or even oil fired) on-site generation systems (which provide emergency power supply in case of a blackout of the grid or in other situations), with hydrogen. We anticipate the first data centers  globally, but also in Europe, to use such hydrogen on-site generators will come to market soon. While such on-site generators are currently only used for emergency situations, the longer term future might be to have larger on-site generator units which may  help to close the gap and allow for the (full) generation of energy on-site. This would require hydrogen supply pipelines around data center hubs (as being considered in Frankfurt currently, for example). 

Option 3 – To make effective use of the heat generated 

The third approach is to make effective use of the heat generated on-site. This can be achieved, for example, by transferring the recovered heat to district heating networks. In January 2023, the Frankfurt-based utility and data center operator signed a memorandum of understanding for a joint project on the sustainable use of waste heat and announced that data centers could provide excess heat to Frankfurt’s district heating network. A data center in the Digital Park Fechenheim – currently under construction – could become the first to feed its waste heat into the city-wide district heating network and meet the heating requirements of around 3,600 households. Frankfurt could therefore serve as an example for the effective use of recovered heat in the context of supplying households.

Key recommendations

1

In order to operate data centers in a sustainable manner, the primary goal must be to achieve climate neutrality of said facilities. This requires that the facilities are able to generate on-site energy and the waste of the heat generated through data centers is stopped. 

2

Generators which are still powered by gas must be replaced. As shown, many countries have seen the need for action and try to support projects which aim to transform data centers into climate neutral facilities.

3

Science and politics will need to work hand in hand to achieve climate neutrality for data centers. 

Key contacts